Lucy Chapman, instructed by Ruhenaz Begum of the Royal College of Nursing, mounted a successful article 6 argument, resulting in the acquittal of her client.

Lucy argued that a delay of 4 years 7 months from the beginning of investigation to the date of hearing was unreasonable, such that it breached the registrant’s article 6 right to a fair trial and had caused significant prejudice to her, to proceed with the case would be an abuse of process which could only be remedied by extensive exclusion of evidence, the entirety of which the regulator’s case relied on.

Lucy’s client was a registered mental health nurse in charge of an acute psychiatric unit during a night shift. A vulnerable patient sectioned under the Mental Health Act 1983 managed to abscond out a window resulting in a fall which caused serious injuries including spinal fractures. The patient was on high level observations every 15 minutes due to his risk level. It was alleged Lucy’s client failed to conduct four observations over the course of an hour which allowed the patient to abscond, dishonestly retrospectively completed documentation to cover up her actions, and failed to raise the alarm for 30 minutes after she discovered that the patient had absconded. The trust concerned claimed to have CCTV footage of the registrant’s actions but did not provide this, firstly due to it not being downloadable, and later saying it was no longer available. The regulator sought the CCTV in 2021 but made no efforts to chase this until 4 years later. The regulator relied on a chronology written by the employer witnesses which Lucy argued was demonstrably false by reference to the rest of the evidence, and that the CCTV footage itself was unreliable.

The tribunal agreed that the only way to ensure fairness was to exclude any reference to the CCTV footage and conclusions drawn from it. In response, the regulator offered no evidence to all charges, including one for which an admission was made. The case against the nurse was dismissed.

Lucy’s full profile: https://greatjames.co.uk/members/lucy-chapman/

To instruct Lucy, please contact the clerking team at clerks@greatjames.co.uk or on 0207 440 4949.